Created attachment 73195 [details]
Graph on the left is the current behavior, graph on the left is the expected behavior (now with the manual solution)
Steps to reproduce:
1. Create a Column graph with a value "10" (It works with every value)
2. Insert Y Error Bars, with costant value "10" (The same of first value)
The error bar is out of graph
The Format Axis is setted on "automatic", So I expect that Calc change the scale of the graph, and that the bar is IN the graph.
Operating System: Ubuntu
I believe that this is the same bug or at least the same root cause. If you disagree please open it as NEW but I'm almost positive they are the same.
Thanks for helping us out
*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of bug 52159 ***
I think this is a different bug, because it does not involve copy/pasting the chart outside of Calc. This bug is not about having wrong error bars. It is about the automatic scaling of the axis not considering the error bars, and thus long error bars are often out of the scale. If I remember correctly, this has always been the case (since way before 3.5), so this should be a feature request.
Thanks John for the clear comment, I agree, although it might very well be similar code that is causing the problem. Agreed that this is a NEW (confirmed) issue :-D
I tried it on Rc 188.8.131.52 ...same bug...
@Domenico - please don't change the FDO options if you haven't read about policies.
Version is the oldest version that we see the issue, not the latest it's been tested on, we use comments to say it's been tested on newer versions and still appears.
Version - if it's verified on Linux already, and you verified on Windows mark as "ALL" not Windows (ALL) as it confuses everyone - this is verified on Linux and now Windows so it should be "All".
Thanks for helping out
Sorry, I understand. Just to be clear this bug affect also previus versions of LibreOffice...certainly 3.5
ah then the version should be changed to the earliest that you are 100% sure it existed :-D
Yes, I am pretty sure that this automatic error-bar scaling feature was never in the 3.5 series. But I don't think this is a critical bug, it's more of an enhancement.
Actually I don't agree if we call this enhancement. Users will see this like a dataloss or malfunction.
I can confirm this in LO 184.108.40.206
Ideally, there should be an option to tick like "Include error bars in chart area", because sometimes error bars can be "over the top"...
This annoying thing is present in last LO version 6.0.2