Hello XP-SP3 - LibO 3.2.99.2 - buildid=330m9(Build:1) Tools > Options > Load/Save > General > "Always create backup copy" is unchecked Even if we can assume that performance research is the reason why this option is unchecked it should always be checked by default Safety should take precedence over performance Best regards
I don't think this is an issue of performance but rather space, if you always create a backup copy then you will have double the amount of documents you create ( in a non-obvious location ) Additionally the backup may not do exactly what you thing, the back up keeps the *previous* version of the file and not the version you just saved. In these circumstances it is quite reasonable to make this a non-default option. Note: autorecovery is enabled by default
Thank's for reply... > I don't think this is an issue of performance but rather space, if you always > create a backup copy then you will have double the amount of documents you > create ( in a non-obvious location ) That may indeed be the reason ... If that is the case we could consider adding a parameter max occupancy or shelf life. > Additionally the backup may not do exactly > what you thing, the back up keeps the *previous* version of the file and not > the version you just saved. Yes I know and I know I do not take this proposal out of nowhere. The file corruption problems are so regular on the french forum that a section had their being dedicated : http://user.services.openoffice.org/fr/forum/viewforum.php?f=35 I also wrote a mini tutorial on this issue : http://user.services.openoffice.org/fr/forum/viewtopic.php?f=29&t=24511 The fact that problems often come from poor use of USB support does not diminish the loss of the document and the disappointment of users to discover "after the fact" that one option could have them save their document. Note that this request is also included in the survey: http://wiki.services.openoffice.org/wiki/User_Experience/Improving_OOo_Default_Settings > In these circumstances it is quite reasonable to > make this a non-default option. Well this is a point of view but I do not share
(In reply to comment #2) > > I don't think this is an issue of performance but rather space, if you always > > create a backup copy then you will have double the amount of documents you > > create ( in a non-obvious location ) > > That may indeed be the reason ... If that is the case we could consider adding > a parameter max occupancy or shelf life. > I don't know that introducing even more options in this area would make things clearer :-( > > Additionally the backup may not do exactly > > what you thing, the back up keeps the *previous* version of the file and not > > the version you just saved. > > Yes I know and I know I do not take this proposal out of nowhere. The file > corruption problems are so regular on the french forum that a section had their > being dedicated : > http://user.services.openoffice.org/fr/forum/viewforum.php?f=35 [...] don't read french but.... would be even better to get to the root cause of what sounds like endemic corruption problems > Note that this request is also included in the survey: > http://wiki.services.openoffice.org/wiki/User_Experience/Improving_OOo_Default_Settings that's interesting, but I suppose it doesn't either indicate the amount of support for changing that option or not. > > > In these circumstances it is quite reasonable to > > make this a non-default option. > > Well this is a point of view but I do not share :-) sure, and the beauty of this project is that it is in your power to change things, a) poke the list, see if there are any major objections to making this change ( and the change required I would guess probably doesn't even require coding but just finding the correct config file in the build tree to change ) b) propose a patch c) submit the patch chances are it will even get accepted :-)
Hello. This Issue should no longer be considered as WONTFIX. You should look at the amount of lost data in the "Récupération de documents" section of the french OOo forum, and I guess this is the same thing on other forums. The argument that checking by default the "Always create backup copy" would make too many copies and would need too much disk space is invalid with the disk capacities we have now. We are no longer at the Stone age of computers. I have this option checked, and I am also using an Incremental copy extension, so I have ten or more copies of each of my files, and I am very far from lacking of disk space. The "Always create backup copy" option should be checked by default for beginners who don't know that it exists.Experimented users have always the possibility to uncheck it.
Same problem on Ubuntu 12.04 with
Same problem on Ubuntu 12.04 with LibreOffice 4.2.3.1 Build ID: 3d4fc3d9dbf8f4c0aeb61498a81f91c5b7922f13 If disk space is a problem why create a feature who delete the older backup. The user often need the last backup not the one with there years old ....