With some slide transitions, especially the cools 3d opengl, (really tnx for the awesome work!) would be very useful to "reverse" the transitions effect while moving to the previous slide.
This really helps to visually understand in what direction the presentation is going to.
I don't know if internally (speaking about the code) all transitions could be easy "reverted", maybe, even in this optimistic situation, this behaviour could be automatic or the user could be glad to "check" a "Reverse with previous slide" option.
Let me know,
[This is an automated message.]
This bug was filed before the changes to Bugzilla on 2011-10-16. Thus it
started right out as NEW without ever being explicitly confirmed. The bug is
changed to state NEEDINFO for this reason. To move this bug from NEEDINFO back
to NEW please check if the bug still persists with the 3.5.0 beta1 or beta2 prereleases.
Details on how to test the 3.5.0 beta1 can be found at:
more detail on this bulk operation: http://nabble.documentfoundation.org/RFC-Operation-Spamzilla-tp3607474p3607474.html
Thanks for interesting idea. Let me add some small ideas to it:
1. Usually users want to quick scroll to some of previous slide. Effects in this situation will only slow down this search.
2. Many effects is symmetric, so impossible understand direction.
3. Combinations of effect may be so complex that impossible something understand at all (for example if presentation used as QUIZ)
4. in animation may used sound, animated GIF, video. What with them?
PS: in current slide we can go to previous animation using buttons with arrows
(In reply to comment #2)
Sorry I didn't get if we're talking specifically about the same thing or if you simply add more stuff. I try to clarify my point in case I was misunderstood :p
I set a 3d cube transition effect to all my slides.
Then going forward the cube rotate (naturally) from left to right (clockwise virtually looking from the upper side).
Going to the previous slide the cube again rotate clockwise, instead the more naturally counter-clockwise.
So for all the slide transition effects (and not other kind of effects for animation.. etc) where they have a direction, "simply" support the reverse going to the previous slide.
> Thanks for interesting idea. Let me add some small ideas to it:
> 1. Usually users want to quick scroll to some of previous slide. Effects in
> this situation will only slow down this search.
Did you mean to disable slide transitions effects going to previous slides?
No bad idea, but I think that would be a feature explicitly addressed for the "advanced" user.
Anyway I think there are better way to allow the user to quick scroll to some of previous slides, see http://impressive.sourceforge.net/
(Give it a try if you don't know it... really deserve! and would be great add those features in libreoffice!)
> 2. Many effects is symmetric, so impossible understand direction.
> 3. Combinations of effect may be so complex that impossible something
> understand at all (for example if presentation used as QUIZ)
> 4. in animation may used sound, animated GIF, video. What with them?
> PS: in current slide we can go to previous animation using buttons with arrows
Thanks for additional explanations
We speak here about slide transition, not about animation (my misunderstood)
fedora 18 32 bit - GNOME 3.6.2 - 188.8.131.52 LO
Windows 7 pro 32 bit - LO 184.108.40.206
Sounds like a very good idea to add this behavior to the transitions in LO. The idea is similar to what happens in MS Office Power Point, and really gives visual continuity to the presentation.
Moreover, in an actual presentation to quickly switch to a particular slide, you can use the presenter console, or the new LibreOffice Impress remote. The point is that if a slide that is after the current transition is displayed in the normal sense, but if the slide is before the current slide, the transition is displayed in reverse.
Description of the problem:
Add that currently inconsistent behavior occurs when moving forward or backward a slide (with transition effect). When you move back a slide: ↑ or ← or PgUp simply appears the previous slide. When using the contextual menu / previous slide back, but showing the effect transition "normal sense" being inconsistent and confusing.
1. Prepare a presentation with at least 3 slides (with the same transition effect)
2. Try moving forward the presentation
3. now move backward presentation (with: ↑ or ← or PgUp)
4. Back to advance. Now go back to the context menu / previous (compare with 3)
Going forward (any method) is displayed normal transition when backward (any method) is shown in the opposite transition.
Created attachment 75433 [details]
Videos that illustrate the inconsistent behavior transitions
Take the test with similar transitions (cube effect) both in LO 4.0 (fedora) and MS Office 2013 on the same computer.
zip archive videos:
1. move next / previous in Office 2013 (ideal behavior in LO)
2. move next / previous in LO 4.0 (sorry for the performance of transitions)
3. inconsistent behavior shows transitions in LO 4.0
This would make it more consistent with MS Powerpoint which already has this! (from ppt 2010)
See this quote from MS Forums:
I've created a presentation in PowerPoint with a 'Push Left' transition between all slides.
This looks great - until you view it in Slide Show and hit the back button. The transition remains as 'Push Left' although the slide content changes to the previous content. As a user this is very confusing.
This is no longer necessary with PowerPoint 2010. All the transitions support backward/forward appropriately.