Created attachment 154569 [details]
border dialog 01
Main issues of the boarders tab is:
- shadow group is not together in one group (one column)
- Labels are top align only at padding group the labels are left align
- Shadow Style is together in one group so it's clear that the three settings are for shadow
- Labels should be according to the HIG or the config dialog left align. The benefit is better readability and better alignment between the different groups. The issue is that you need more horizontal width, which is not really an issue, cause of widescreen's AND the minimal size of dialogues in general.
While the proposal follows the rules it looks less balanced than before. One problem is the labeling of multiple controls similar to single elements. You never do things like
Option 1 (o)
Another Option 2 ( )
Whatever Option 3 ( )
( ) Another Second
( ) Whatever Third
So we should do the same perhaps for those combined controls here. Meaning Presets, User-defined, and Position are to be placed above the set. Might work for the first two but not for Position (I like the grouping for Shadow options).
Ultimately, a guideline is nothing you have to follow strictly without exception.
"Merge with..."/Properties in the middle column looks displaced. I would put it at bottom left. And last but not least it's desirable to have equally sized columns, if possible.
Created attachment 154664 [details]
border dialog 02
thanks for the feedback heiko. what do you think?
(In reply to andreas_k from comment #2)
> Created attachment 154664 [details]
Presets and User-defined content has too much indentation. And it looks like padding is related to the shadow.
I share the opinion of Heiko in comment 3.
Maybe it helps if you change the arrangements of the sections:
Line Arrangement Padding
Line Shadow Style
On the current arrangement of the border tab I like that it's good readable for Western LTR users:
Line Arrangement -> Line -> Padding
The other sections are less important and in the bottom part of the dialog (Shadow Style, Properties).
What I don't like in the current dialog is that Shadow Style is streched over 3 rows what it shouldn't. This is better realized in your proposal, Andreas.
I'm not sure if the height of the dialog is too large. In my current LibreOffice installation on Ubuntu the dialog is more wide than high. In your proposal it's more like a square.
I would position "Merge Adjacent line styles" above Shadow Styles.
It is related to the settings above there.
UX input given, removing the keyword.
Created attachment 155135 [details]
border dialog 03
- No change
- labels are on top
- labels are left align like in Padding (or in most groups)
- one compact group in the second column
- group on the left
- no change
(In reply to andreas_k from comment #7)
> Shadow Style
> - one compact group in the second column
Not a fan of those random columns but the shadow group is an advantage.
I saw that Shadow is in Border but the property is table related (you can't shadow an specific selection) so the question is should the shadow items be located in border or better in table.
Created attachment 155325 [details]
border dialog 04
Now I'm fine with the dialog.
It's compact has only two columns and the groups are related to each other
Line Arrangement - > Line
Shadow Style and Padding are secondary settings Properties are aditonal settings.
In principle it's good. But the right columns seems to align at the right border (without sufficient margins). I would place it right of the left column with some spacing. And we talked at another dialog about textual controls (dropdowns) and numeric (spinner) that shouldn't resize equally.
04 looks good except Heiko's hint in his last comment.
The option columns should align to the left and should be arranged in equally widths with a spacing between columns. Is this defined somewhere?
(In reply to Thomas Lendo from comment #12)
> Is this defined somewhere?
The guideline is in draft.