After some research and not finding anything concerning this issu, I'm forwarding this bug found in the newly released LibO 126.96.36.199 All former comments and newly created comments in calc, disappear when file is saved in this version.
Steps to reproduce
1. Open a spreadsheet file in LibO 188.8.131.52 or any older version
2. Place a comment in any cell
3. Save and close the file
4. Open again the file and modify then save again.
5. Close again
On editing the comment has disappeard.
Hope that this can help. Feel free to ask for further details.
Created attachment 93165 [details]
comment in A1 cell
not reproducible under Win7 64bit using 184.108.40.206
tray loading the attached file. do you see that comment in the A1 cell?
(In reply to comment #1)
> Created attachment 93165 [details]
> comment in A1 cell
> not reproducible under Win7 64bit using 220.127.116.11
> tray loading the attached file. do you see that comment in the A1 cell?
tommy27 - I can see the comment. Can you do the same by closing completly LibO. I tried both, closing the file and closing LibO. I got the same result. My comment just disappeard.
I still see the comment I created.
what happens to you with my file? does the comment disappears from my file after reloading it in Linux?
which exact distibution do you run?
(In reply to comment #3)
> I still see the comment I created.
> what happens to you with my file? does the comment disappears from my file
> after reloading it in Linux?
> which exact distibution do you run?
I tested with your file and the comment is there. When I modified the file, saved it and then open it again, I still have the same result; the comment is gone.
I'm under UBUNTU 13.10 AMD 64 - LibO 18.104.22.168 Ubuntu version
Duplicate of bug 74325
*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of bug 74325 ***