Created attachment 106706 [details] ms office open file screen Problem description: ms excel 2000 於存檔時，在存檔畫面 -> 工具 -> 一般選項 -> 建議唯讀 被打勾的情形下，正常使用ms excel 2000 開啟檔案時，會跳出選擇是否唯讀的選項。 可是，Libreoffice確直接進入唯讀，無法撰擇是否唯讀。使得無法使用Libreoffice編輯。 Steps to reproduce: 1. ms excel 2000 Save > 工具 > 一般選項 > 建議唯讀 打勾 2. 使用ms excel 2000 open file 3. 會跳出視窗，選擇"否"，即可編輯文件 4. 使用Libreoffice open file 5. 直接進入唯讀模式，不可編輯文件 Current behavior: 如果需要編輯，只有使用 ms excel 來編輯。 Expected behavior: 如果有唯讀選項，也可在開啟前或開啟後，用來可以解除，方便編輯文件。 Operating System: Windows XP的中 Version: 4.3.1.2 release
Hi s85b1023, Report has to be written in English to be understandable by everyone. Can you translate it?
Sorry, my e-mail was gone quick a little. I understood that you cannot, with LibreOffice, write modifications into a document with lecture only attrinbute. Is this correct? regards, Jacques
Hi jacques I tried to give it a try Please wait for some time Thank you for your reply s85b1023 2014-09-23 21:37 GMT+08:00 <bugzilla-daemon@freedesktop.org>: > *Comment # 1 <https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=84224#c1> on > bug 84224 <https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=84224> from Jacques > Guilleron <guilleron29@aol.com> * > > Hi s85b1023, > > Report has to be written in English to be understandable by everyone. Can you > translate it? > > ------------------------------ > You are receiving this mail because: > > - You reported the bug. > >
--------- Translation: Problem description: When you save a file in ms excel 2010, on the file save dialog there is "Tools -> General Option -> Suggest Read Only" option (translated). When this option is enabled when you save a file, next time when you open this file with ms excel there will be a dialog pops up asking you whether you want to open the file read-only or edit the file. But when you open such a file (the file saved with "Suggest Read Only" option enabled) in LibreOffice, it's only possible to open read-only, no way to edit the file in LibreOffice. Steps to reproduce: 1. In ms excel 2010, Save > Tools > General Options, enable "Suggest Read Only. 2. Open the saved file with ms excel 2000 open file 3. A dialog pops up (to let you decide whether you want to open in read-only mode), select "no" so you can edit the file. 4. Open the saved file with Libreoffice. 5. The file is open read-only in LibreOffice, you can not edit it. ---------- I reproduce with LibreOffice version 4.3.3.1, set to NEW.
Created attachment 107909 [details] a test xlsx file saved with "Read-only recommended" mode enabled in Excel 2010
When unzip the attached test xlsx file, I see the following: docProps\app.xml: ... <DocSecurity>2</DocSecurity> ... See here: http://www.sno.phy.queensu.ca/~phil/exiftool/TagNames/OOXML.html OOXML Tags DocSecurity 1 = Password protected 2 = Read-only recommended 4 = Read-only enforced 8 = Locked for annotations
Hi all.. I think we can edit/modify the file by clicking "Edit File" icon, then saving the file also allowed. Though we're still missing pop up dialog box as shown in Excel.
Created attachment 107914 [details] screenshot showing where the "Edit File" icon is
Per comment 7, mark this as WORKSFOEME. Will file a new enhancement request re the pop-up notification dialog issue.
New enhancement bug filed as Bug 85080.