Created attachment 124634 [details] Test case: page-break-before on paragraph after table The attached document has a table, immediately followed by a paragraph which is set to have a page break before it. (Right click -> "Paragraph" -> "Text Flow" tab -> "Breaks") When saving this file to docx format, a file is produced which Microsoft Word cannot open. I think this is because a text run <w:r> containing a page break is inserted as a child of the body element <w:body>, but text run elements are not allowed there. Steps to reproduce: 1) in LibreOffice open the attached pagebreakaftertable.odt 2) save as .docx, close 3) try to open the docx file in Microsoft Word - fails with "Unspecified error" in /word/document.xml 4) try to open the docx file in LibreOffice: it actually opens but note that the page break has been lost
Created attachment 124727 [details] .odt with table and paragraph with page-break-before I am setting status NEW and keywords regression, bisected. As Luke's attachment is a .docx, I created the attached dbgutil_20160427.odt. In each version under test, I did... (1) Open dbgutil_20160427.odt from the command line. (2) Save as Microsoft Word 2006-2013 XML (.docx) (3) Close the documemnt. (4) In Start Center, take menu options File > "Recent Documents" and open the just-saved .docx. Working in the 43max bibisect repository, I have reached ... 7c61549622652f6e098fd66456c2d98efeff27fa is the first bad commit commit 7c61549622652f6e098fd66456c2d98efeff27fa Author: Matthew Francis <mjay.francis@gmail.com> Date: Thu May 28 19:31:39 2015 +0800 source-hash-a31fbb53dba76736b37213b98b64937f05929a67 commit a31fbb53dba76736b37213b98b64937f05929a67 Author: Pallavi Jadhav <pallavi.jadhav@synerzip.com> AuthorDate: Thu Feb 6 13:58:03 2014 +0530 Commit: Miklos Vajna <vmiklos@collabora.co.uk> CommitDate: Wed Feb 26 10:50:08 2014 +0100 fdo#74566:DOCX: Preservation <w:br> tag for Break to Next Page Issue : 'Break to Next Page' gets converted to 'Page Break Before' in RT. XML diffrenece : - LO exports <w:br> as <w:pageBreakBefore /> in document.xml - The page break is written into wrong paragraph. Implementation : 1] Removed implementation to export <w:pageBreakBefore />. 2] Added a check to write <w:br> in correct paragraph. 3] Modified code to handle SectionBreak() even if Text node has no string. It is required when DOCX contains a PageBreak with footer. 4] Written Export Unit Test case. Conflicts: sw/qa/extras/ooxmlexport/ooxmlexport.cxx Reviewed on: https://gerrit.libreoffice.org/7891 Change-Id: I237b9c5fdd3083b441f6e81cd8442f458eccf1a0 Bugzilla search shows several possible dups or near misses. I am arbitrarily choosing to confirm this report.
the commit early 2014 makes it good to set 4.3 as first affected version
broken in 5.1.4 Works for me - 5.3 and 5.1.5 Almost certainly fixed by bug 99090 since a bibisect of when the bug was fixed falls into that range.