My adventure with this bug started with an attempt to reproduce
bug 85861. This one is different in that:
(*) My problem is high CPU usage instead of a crash.
(*) My problem happens earlier in the STR.
STR, using daily dbgutil bibisect repository version 2014-11-04:
(0) Download the .odt file attached to bug 85861
(1) Optionally, run System Monitor, or `top`, or something to show you
(2) Open the .odt from the command line. Program displays page 1
of 91. Observe heading "1.11 COORDENADA" about 1/3 of the way
down the page.
(3) If the Navigator window is not open, type <F5>. The list area of
the navigator window blinks briefly about once per second.
(4) In the Navigator window, expand Headings > "PARTE I: LAS LEYES
HATURALES" > 1.1 and then double click "1.11 COORDENADAS".
(a) In the document area, the cursor moves to start of heading
(b) In the Navigator window, line "1.11 COORDENADAS" is
highlighted and it moves to the top of the list area.
(c) About once per second for half a minute or so, the list area
is blanked briefly or the scrollbars are blanked briefly.
(d) Gradually the CPU usage increases to 100%. I have let the
program run this way for as long as a few minutes.
(5) Type <Alt>+F <Alt>+X. Program exits, as commanded.
Working in the daily dbgutil bibisect repository, I ignored
differences in the quality of the blinking Navigator window,
uncommanded collapse or not of the list after the double click in Step
(4), and repositioning (or not) of the list after the double-click.
In short, I called the loop "bad" and anything else "good". Most
importantly, I ran each version of LibreOffice with its own user
profile. The result, in short:
version commit s-h behaviour
---------- ------- ------- --------
2014-05-23 aa51564 c68c5e7 no loop
2014-05-24 20faa9b 474f484 loop
However, if I then run version 2014-05-23 with user profile previously
created by 2014-05-24, the program again loops.
For comparison, I see no loop in version:
Build ID: 768d22a83e7e6aae430b2e5e4ed28f2574aad12d
TinderBox: Win-x86@39, Branch:master, Time: 2014-11-04_09:19:00
In the interval c68c5e7..474f484 I see 181 commits. My naive
attention goes to:
Author: Ulrich Kitzinger <email@example.com>
Date: Fri May 23 09:10:57 2014 +0200
Resolves: fdo#58187 Expand and Collapse should be virtual
regression from ac7acb0ab1329913b0cec79790adcde0263960be
Comparing the two user profile directories as they were after the
first execution of the particular versions of LibreOffice, I see that
user/registrymodifications.xcu for version 2014-05-24 (the version
which looped) has extra lines 3 through 9, to which I add whitespace
<prop oor:name="ShowListBox" oor:op="fuse">
<prop oor:name="SelectedPosition" oor:op="fuse">
<prop oor:name="RootType" oor:op="fuse">
<prop oor:name="InsertMode" oor:op="fuse">
<prop oor:name="OutlineLevel" oor:op="fuse">
<prop oor:name="GlobalDocMode" oor:op="fuse">
<prop oor:name="ActiveBlock" oor:op="fuse">
On pc Debian x86-64 with master sources updated yesterday, I reproduced this partly.
I mean, I reproduced:
but not 4)d) the cpu increases but then decreases.
Anyway the cpu consumption is quite weird, so putting at NEW.
Michael Stahl committed a patch related to this issue.
It has been pushed to "master":
fdo#85886 don't redraw the Navigator content tree if nothing changed
It will be available in 4.4.0.
The patch should be included in the daily builds available at
http://dev-builds.libreoffice.org/daily/ in the next 24-48 hours. More
information about daily builds can be found at:
Affected users are encouraged to test the fix and report feedback.
i've noticed 2 problems here:
1. when the navigator is displayed a timer fires once a second
and fetches the entire content from the document and re-draws;
this is a "regression" in so far as before commit
6eaad9e41ae95a3d973e72439ef580349e3e8e4b the navigator was
pretty much broken...
2. the layout is not stable; on the last page there is an
osciallation where a paragraph and some fly invalidate
each other forever eating up 10-15% of a (pretty fast)
CPU with --enable-dbgutil (no optimizations);
this can be reproduced in current libreoffice-4-3, 4.2.6
and 3.5.7 too which is the earliest version for which
i've got a dbgutil build with the green/red pixel...
of course the 2nd problem is independent from having the navigator
i've pushed a patch that may help with the 1st problem;
if you get a high CPU load without the navigator open
it's probably 2nd problem which doesn't look like a regression
and should be a separate bug;
if you still see very high CPU load only with navigator open
please re-open this bug.
Thank you, Michael. Good work. More specifically ...
W.r.t. problem 1:
(*) In daily dbgutil bibisect repository version 2014-11-22, which now
embeds the Navigator into the Sidebar, I see no flashing of the
navigator, and with the sidebar open LibreOffice is using about 3%
of my CPU.
This is a clear improvement from the version of 2014-11-21, where
the flashing was conspicuous and CPU usage with the navigator open
was about 25%.
(*) In Widows TinderBox from 2014-11-21_23:15:55, with the Navigator
open, I see no flashing and the CPU usage is nil.
This is an improvement over TinderBox from 2014-11-21_00:01:14,
where the Navigator flashes conspicuously and the program used 20%
of the CPU, reducing later to 3 to 5 percent.
W.r.t. problem 2:
I have not seen this problem at all. I see no visible redrawing of
the last page, and without Navigator, the CPU usage in the later
version on Linux eventually settles down to 1 to 3 percent.
I think I should not file the bug report for this one.
About the fact that your CPU usage dropped back instead of staying
pegged as in my step (4)(d):
I think this is plausibly explained by the timer that Michael
mentioned in comment 3 and the assumption that your CPU is faster than
mine. I could play around to test this assumption, but I shall do
that only if you can see some value in it.
libreoffice-4-4 commit is b5c1f352522c34a744ad0226e73904ce5af81b11
Reopened because still seeing constant cpu usage with the Navigator opened.
Using this document as an example: https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/images/2/2f/WG42-WriterGuideLO.odt
With the Navigator open I am seeing a constant 15% cpu usage and scrolling through the document is slow. If the Navigator is closed or has focus, the cpu drops down.
This is in the Win version.
Build ID: 45e2de17089c24a1fa810c8f975a7171ba4cd432
(In reply to Gordo from comment #7)
> Reopened because still seeing constant cpu usage with the Navigator opened.
Sounds like this bug does not meet the criteria for Status 'REOPENED'
Status back to -> VERIFIED FIXED
Please file a new bug regarding your Navigator problems, and we can triage that issue separately. Thanks!
Migrating Whiteboard tags to Keywords: (bibisected, perf)