Page style setting confusing
Steps to Reproduce:
1. Open the attached file
2. Format Page Style for the first page -> Notice the next style being Landscape. Change it.. Nothing happens
3. Go to page 2 -> Format - Page Style -> Change the next style to landscape -> It's applied to the next page
Reason: Format -> Paragraph -> Text Flow -> Breaks -> insert with page style on page 2.
It's confusing having two settings for setting page style in different dialog which interact with each other without being visible at once
Not sure how to fix this, but current solution is rather confusing IMHO
User Profile Reset: No
Version: 220.127.116.11.alpha0+ (x64)
Build ID: <buildversion>
CPU threads: 4; OS: Windows 6.3 Build 9600; UI render: Skia/Raster; VCL: win
Locale: nl-NL (nl_NL); UI: en-US
Created attachment 164350 [details]
I confirm this. I tried 5 minutes to find WHY this problem. And I had to read Telesto comment to find why. Should be an altert, something that the next page is already setup by a different component.
We last did this dance for bug 126608 -- the 'Default Page Style' has been changed from template defaults.
Anyhow one of the observations there was that bug 41316 is involved, but that ODF 1.3 provides no relief.
Adding R. Green into the loop. He had some issues in this area
(In reply to Telesto from comment #0)
> 2. Format Page Style for the first page -> Notice the next style being
> Landscape. Change it.. Nothing happens
If you add a manual page break with a special page style you shouldn't expect the application to override¹. Just force a page break (ctrl+enter) and get the landscape styled next page (before the differently formatted 3rd page).
I don't see an issue, => WFM. Maybe bug 134557 for better feedback.
¹ Blue dotted line between pages indicates the page break. Click it and use Edit Page Break to also get to the text flow setting.
(In reply to Heiko Tietze from comment #5)
> (In reply to Telesto from comment #0)
> > 2. Format Page Style for the first page -> Notice the next style being
> > Landscape. Change it.. Nothing happens
> If you add a manual page break with a special page style you shouldn't
> expect the application to override¹.
-> Not the point of course. I never said it should. However, the current way of managing things isn't to user friendly. Even if from technical point of view correct. This about accessibility. If there are more menu's. In circumstances doing the same thing, and under different circumstances doing different things, it becomes rather hard.
Especially if you don't know all aspects of the document design. You might the work of somebody else.
The styles inspector might show it, but surely not the holy grail.
For record, all the see also are more or less expressions of the same 'fundamental' issue GUI wise. [Not functionality wise]
I use LibreOffice since 2012 and I didn't find alone how to change this.
Maybe a red mesage should inform that the same properties is changed in another place by something else and how to change that.
(In reply to BogdanB from comment #7)
> I use LibreOffice since 2012 and I didn't find alone how to change this.
You never looked at the Stylist with page styles being selected?
Besides that the request "It's confusing having two settings for setting page style" is vague no expectation is made. One solution is to RTFM, another trial and error with a clear workflow.
Potential advanced solution is the style highlighting idea, bug 38194, bug 106556, and bug 34002, see also . If we extend the idea to page styles we could show a bar in the document's margin that indicates what PgS is applied.
Removing UX for now.
These bug reports just need to be closed. Ultimately, the human needs to learn the tool they are using.